Analysis and commentary on the business of technology

The Bay Table

From Snowflake and Peloton to Stripe and Wiz, what public and private markets paid for, and what governments allowed.

Listings, deals and the rules of the road

  • Public investors paid $70bn for Snowflake's retention ratio, not its earnings, and the price holds only if that ratio decays slowly.
  • Stripe's down round is the cheapest way to reset a private valuation, and founders who wait for an IPO will pay more.
  • Washington's three-tier AI chip rule protects the right things and punishes America's own customers.

Markets pay for stories and then wait to see which ones are true. This week we look at what investors paid for Snowflake and Peloton, why Stripe was right to take its haircut early, how Google's $32bn bet on Wiz depends on a promise, and why Adobe's abandoned bid for Figma was a good outcome. In policy, we weigh America's tiered rule for AI chips, the Dutch licence rule for ASML, the fine on Apple in Brussels and the deal that keeps TikTok in America. Terman asks whether Instagram's teen accounts will hold.

Leaders

  1. Adobe, Figma and merger review

    Regulators were right about Figma

    Regulators were right to stop Adobe buying a rival before it grew, and Figma’s founders, who kept $1bn and their independence, should be the model for startups that are courted.

Business & Finance

  1. Peloton’s IPO · Giannini

    Peloton is priced as software, built as a bike

    Peloton’s investors paid a software multiple for a business that sells mostly exercise equipment, and the first day of trading suggests some of them noticed.

  2. Snowflake’s IPO · Giannini

    Snowflake’s price is a retention bet

    Public investors paid $70bn for a growth rate and a retention ratio, not for earnings, and the price holds only if that ratio decays far more slowly than history suggests.

  3. Stripe’s down round · Giannini

    Stripe takes its haircut early

    Stripe’s round at $50bn, nearly half its 2021 price, is the cheapest way to reset a private valuation, and founders who wait for an IPO to do it will pay more.

  4. Google and Wiz · Giannini

    Google’s $32bn buys a promise

    Google has agreed to pay $32bn for Wiz, and the price is justified only if Google keeps its pledge to leave the firm neutral between rival clouds.

Policy & Regulation

  1. Dutch chip export rules · Warren

    The Hague draws a narrow line

    The Netherlands’ licence rule for ASML’s best immersion machines is narrow enough to defend, and The Hague should keep it that way.

  2. Apple and music streaming · Warren

    Apple’s gag rule earned its fine

    The European Commission is right that Apple abused its App Store power over music apps, but a €1.8bn fine justified by harm it cannot measure is a weaker weapon than the order to scrap the rule.

  3. Instagram’s Teen Accounts · Terman

    Instagram gets the default right

    Meta’s move to put every under-18 on Instagram into a private, restricted account by default is the right design, but it will be judged by how many teenagers stay in it, and Meta has not said how it will find out.

  4. The AI diffusion rule · Warren

    Tiering the world will cost America

    Commerce is right to control model weights and to keep advanced chips from China, but a three-tier caste system for everyone else punishes America’s own customers.

  5. The TikTok deal · Warren

    TikTok’s sale rewrites the law

    The joint venture that keeps TikTok in America is a sensible outcome that the 2024 law does not strictly allow, and Congress should amend the statute rather than let an executive order do it.

Peloton’s IPO. Peloton’s investors paid a software multiple for a business that sells mostly exercise equipment, and the first day of trading suggests some of them noticed. Read more on Peloton is priced as software, built as a bike

Snowflake’s IPO. Public investors paid $70bn for a growth rate and a retention ratio, not for earnings, and the price holds only if that ratio decays far more slowly than history suggests. Read more on Snowflake’s price is a retention bet

Stripe’s down round. Stripe’s round at $50bn, nearly half its 2021 price, is the cheapest way to reset a private valuation, and founders who wait for an IPO to do it will pay more. Read more on Stripe takes its haircut early

Dutch chip export rules. The Netherlands’ licence rule for ASML’s best immersion machines is narrow enough to defend, and The Hague should keep it that way. Read more on The Hague draws a narrow line

Adobe, Figma and merger review. Regulators were right to stop Adobe buying a rival before it grew, and Figma’s founders, who kept $1bn and their independence, should be the model for startups that are courted. Read more on Regulators were right about Figma

Apple and music streaming. The European Commission is right that Apple abused its App Store power over music apps, but a €1.8bn fine justified by harm it cannot measure is a weaker weapon than the order to scrap the rule. Read more on Apple’s gag rule earned its fine

Instagram’s Teen Accounts. Meta’s move to put every under-18 on Instagram into a private, restricted account by default is the right design, but it will be judged by how many teenagers stay in it, and Meta has not said how it will find out. Read more on Instagram gets the default right

The AI diffusion rule. Commerce is right to control model weights and to keep advanced chips from China, but a three-tier caste system for everyone else punishes America’s own customers. Read more on Tiering the world will cost America

Google and Wiz. Google has agreed to pay $32bn for Wiz, and the price is justified only if Google keeps its pledge to leave the firm neutral between rival clouds. Read more on Google’s $32bn buys a promise

The TikTok deal. The joint venture that keeps TikTok in America is a sensible outcome that the 2024 law does not strictly allow, and Congress should amend the statute rather than let an executive order do it. Read more on TikTok’s sale rewrites the law