Adobe has agreed to pay $1bn to not own Figma.2FortuneAdobe to pay Figma a $1B breakup fee after European regulators scuttle proposed merger18 Dec 2023 The fee, which Adobe owes after the two companies called off their $20bn merger on December 18th, is about 5% of the price it had agreed to pay in September 2022, and Figma collects it for doing nothing at all.1AdobeAdobe and Figma Mutually Agree to Terminate Merger Agreement18 Dec 2023,2FortuneAdobe to pay Figma a $1B breakup fee after European regulators scuttle proposed merger18 Dec 2023 Few rivals in the history of software have been so well rewarded for refusing to be bought.

The companies blame regulators. Adobe and Figma said they saw “no clear path” to approval from the European Commission and Britain’s Competition and Markets Authority (CMA), and Adobe’s chief executive, Shantanu Narayen, said both firms “strongly disagree with the recent regulatory findings”.1AdobeAdobe and Figma Mutually Agree to Terminate Merger Agreement18 Dec 2023,2FortuneAdobe to pay Figma a $1B breakup fee after European regulators scuttle proposed merger18 Dec 2023 We think the regulators were right. Adobe was paying a very large sum for a company that might have grown into its competitor, and the right to do that is the thing merger review exists to examine. We also think the lesson for founders is the less obvious one: the break fee, and the independence it bought, were worth more than the deal.

Start with the regulators’ case. Adobe sells Photoshop and Illustrator; Figma is the tool most professional interface designers now use, which the CMA put at around 80% of the market.3Competition and Markets AuthorityAdobe/Figma deal could harm UK digital design sector28 Nov 2023 The CMA provisionally found that the deal would remove competition between them in product design, image editing and illustration. It also found that Adobe had dropped its own product design tool, a step it linked to the merger.3Competition and Markets AuthorityAdobe/Figma deal could harm UK digital design sector28 Nov 2023 The Commission, for its part, said Figma “exerts a significant constraining influence on Adobe’s vector editing tool” and that the deal was “likely to create a dominant player”.4ComputerworldEU Commission issues objections to Adobe’s $20B Figma acquisition20 Nov 2023 Margrethe Vestager, the EU’s competition chief, said the combination would have “terminated all current and prevented all future competition” between the two.2FortuneAdobe to pay Figma a $1B breakup fee after European regulators scuttle proposed merger18 Dec 2023

Now the strongest counter-argument. Figma, the companies insisted, does not compete with Adobe in image editing and has no plans to.3Competition and Markets AuthorityAdobe/Figma deal could harm UK digital design sector28 Nov 2023 Regulators were punishing a deal for what might happen, and that is a bad habit. Startups depend on being bought: if the biggest buyer is barred, the price falls and the next founder sees one less reason to start. Margot Daly, who chaired the CMA’s inquiry, called the findings “provisional”, after all.3Competition and Markets AuthorityAdobe/Figma deal could harm UK digital design sector28 Nov 2023

Yet the argument proves too little. A forecast of competition is the only kind of evidence there is for a young firm, and here Adobe’s own conduct supplied the data: it had stopped building a rival product while the deal was pending.3Competition and Markets AuthorityAdobe/Figma deal could harm UK digital design sector28 Nov 2023 Figma accepted an offer reported to be double its valuation at a time when many peers were being marked down, a price that looks like a premium for removing a rival.2FortuneAdobe to pay Figma a $1B breakup fee after European regulators scuttle proposed merger18 Dec 2023 An incumbent that buys the contender before the fight has not made a bet on the future. It has cancelled it. Adobe had tried to buy Figma in 2020 and 2021 as well, and that persistence is its own sort of document.2FortuneAdobe to pay Figma a $1B breakup fee after European regulators scuttle proposed merger18 Dec 2023

Nor is the supposed chill on startups obvious. What a startup loses is one buyer’s willingness to pay a premium to stop a rival getting bigger. A founder who stays independent, as Figma now will, can still raise money or sell to a bidder with less overlap. Dylan Field, Figma’s chief executive, said that “regulators don’t see things the same way” but that his company was excited to find other ways to innovate with Adobe.1AdobeAdobe and Figma Mutually Agree to Terminate Merger Agreement18 Dec 2023 That is a founder talking about options, not about a bereavement.

Those options are the real moral. Figma had a large termination fee written into the deal, in effect an insurance policy against exactly this outcome, and it has now paid out.1AdobeAdobe and Figma Mutually Agree to Terminate Merger Agreement18 Dec 2023,2FortuneAdobe to pay Figma a $1B breakup fee after European regulators scuttle proposed merger18 Dec 2023 Founders being courted by a dominant firm should insist on one. They should also price in the clock: the CMA opened its inquiry on May 3rd and it was due to run to February 25th 2024 before the parties gave up on December 18th, some seven months in.5Competition and Markets AuthorityAdobe / Figma merger inquiry18 Dec 2023 A deal the regulators will not like is a deal the buyer must be willing to pay to abandon.

Regulators, for their part, should note that scrutiny works best when it is early, public and reasoned, as the CMA’s was, rather than a surprise in the last month. Adobe’s shareholders seemed unbothered; its shares rose 2.2% in New York trading on the morning of the announcement.2FortuneAdobe to pay Figma a $1B breakup fee after European regulators scuttle proposed merger18 Dec 2023

Figma has been paid a billion dollars to remain Figma. Most startups are paid rather less to disappear.