Analysis and commentary on the business of technology

The Bay Table

Leaders

Our view on the week’s biggest argument in technology, in the house voice.

Klarna and credit

Klarna is a lender after all

Klarna’s listing at a third of its private-market peak shows that buy-now-pay-later is a lender’s business, and its customers and regulators should treat it as one

Algorithmic stablecoins

Stablecoins should hold the dollar they promise

Congress should stop letting tokens that promise a dollar without holding one call themselves stable, and write rules by what a coin promises rather than by who issues it.

Rivian’s listing

Rivian’s investors are buying a story

Investors who pay a Detroit-sized price for a firm that has delivered 156 pickups are buying a story, and should demand that the story be audited like a factory.

Archegos and the banks

Margin for error

Archegos shows that only the banks could see a family office’s leveraged swaps, so the law should make them report what they see.

NFTs and ownership

An NFT buys a receipt, not a picture

Beeple’s $69.3m collage buys a novel but overpriced receipt for a picture anyone can still see, and buyers should be told exactly what it covers.

Nexperia and the state

Dutch courage

The Netherlands was right to stop Nexperia moving its crown jewels abroad, but should give the intervention a deadline and a proper legal home instead of a scarcity law.

Intel and the state

Government inside

Washington’s stake in Intel should be a short loan of patience, with a public timetable to sell, not a permanent seat at the chipmaker’s table

Chips and China

Duty free

An export licence is a judgement about security, not a toll, and a government that takes 15% of what it permits has a reason to permit more.

TSMC in Arizona

Count the wafers, not the pledges

Tariff-driven factory pledges buy goodwill and a headline, not wafers, so Washington should demand schedules and count each dollar once.

Stargate and AI spending

Judge Stargate by what gets built

Stargate’s $500bn is a promise, not a budget, and America should judge it by the data centres that get built and keep Washington out of the cheque-writing

AI and electricity

Make data centres buy their own power

Microsoft’s Three Mile Island restart is the right way for a data centre to buy power, and regulators should make it the rule so households stop footing the bill.

America v Google

Spare the Chrome

Judge Mehta was right to leave Google its browser and phone software, and America should now make the data-sharing order work rather than appeal for a break-up.

The CrowdStrike outage

Blue screen of debt

The CrowdStrike outage shows that firms with deep access to everyone’s computers should be regulated as infrastructure, with staged updates and liability, not as vendors who can disclaim everything.

Acqui-hires and merger review

Review acqui-hires as mergers

Microsoft’s hiring of Inflection’s leaders and staff should be reviewed as the merger it resembles, because a deal that moves a company’s people but not its shares is still a deal

OpenAI’s governance

A charity cannot steer OpenAI

OpenAI’s board did what it was built to do and lost within five days, which shows that competition and the law, not a charity, must steer the lab.

Privacy and power

Apple should obey its own privacy rule

Apple’s tracking prompt is good for users and better for Apple, so regulators should insist that the firm lives under the same rule it imposes on everyone else

Australia v Facebook

Copy Australia’s leverage, not its law

Australia was right that platforms hold too much power over news, but pricing links is clumsy, and other countries should copy the leverage, not the mechanism.

Platform power

Deplatforming needs rules and an appeal

Twitter and Facebook were within their rights to cut off Donald Trump, but a power this large needs published rules and an appeal, not a decision made on a Friday evening