The most closely watched export rule in the chip industry names neither the country it is aimed at nor the company it hits. On June 30th the Dutch government published its licence requirement for advanced chipmaking equipment, and Liesje Schreinemacher, the trade minister, said only that “we have taken this step in the interest of our national security”.1Al JazeeraDutch firms must seek licence before exporting chip gear: Gov’t30 Jun 2023 China was not named.1Al JazeeraDutch firms must seek licence before exporting chip gear: Gov’t30 Jun 2023 Nor, in the letter to parliament in March that first announced the plan, was ASML.2CNBCDutch to restrict semiconductor tech exports to China, joining U.S.9 Mar 2023

Everyone knows who is meant. ASML, based in Veldhoven, is the only maker of the most advanced lithography machines, the devices that print circuits onto silicon. Its ultraviolet (EUV) machines have never been shipped to China.1Al JazeeraDutch firms must seek licence before exporting chip gear: Gov’t30 Jun 2023 The new rule, expected to take effect on September 1st,3Staatscourant, Government of the NetherlandsRegeling geavanceerde productieapparatuur voor halfgeleiders (Staatscourant 2023, 18212)30 Jun 2023 reaches one step down: ASML says its 2000 series immersion machines “and subsequent” models, the top of its deep ultraviolet (DUV) range, will need a licence to be exported.1Al JazeeraDutch firms must seek licence before exporting chip gear: Gov’t30 Jun 2023

We think the Dutch have drawn the line in about the right place. Ms Schreinemacher says only a “very limited” number of companies and product models are affected, and the government promised in March to act “as carefully and precisely as possible” to “avoid unnecessary disruption of value chains”.1Al JazeeraDutch firms must seek licence before exporting chip gear: Gov’t30 Jun 2023 2CNBCDutch to restrict semiconductor tech exports to China, joining U.S.9 Mar 2023 The rule is also country-neutral on its face, a licence for everyone rather than a ban on someone. That matters. A law that names its target invites retaliation against a named target. A law that names a machine invites a licensing clerk.

The commercial cost, on ASML’s own telling, is small. The firm said it would not change its financial guidance and did not expect a material impact.1Al JazeeraDutch firms must seek licence before exporting chip gear: Gov’t30 Jun 2023 The market was less relaxed: ASML’s shares fell 3.6% on the day, and those of ASM International, a smaller rival, fell 1.8%.1Al JazeeraDutch firms must seek licence before exporting chip gear: Gov’t30 Jun 2023 China is a real customer, though not the main one. In March CNBC reported that ASML expected its China sales to stay flat at about €2.2bn in 2023 while total sales grew by about 25%.2CNBCDutch to restrict semiconductor tech exports to China, joining U.S.9 Mar 2023 A business that is growing elsewhere can afford to lose its top tier in one market.

The strongest objection is that the Dutch are doing Washington’s work. The rule followed America’s own controls of October, and reportedly a high-level agreement between America, Japan and the Netherlands.1Al JazeeraDutch firms must seek licence before exporting chip gear: Gov’t30 Jun 2023 Japan had already announced controls on six categories of chipmaking equipment.1Al JazeeraDutch firms must seek licence before exporting chip gear: Gov’t30 Jun 2023 Beijing said in March that it “firmly opposes” the Dutch curbs, calling them the result of “bullying and hegemony”.1Al JazeeraDutch firms must seek licence before exporting chip gear: Gov’t30 Jun 2023 A European champion, runs the argument, should not be a tool of American policy.

There is something in this. Alliances are not equal, and the Dutch were pushed. But the objection assumes the Netherlands has no interest of its own, and it has one. China has set a goal of becoming 70% self-sufficient in semiconductors in 2025.1Al JazeeraDutch firms must seek licence before exporting chip gear: Gov’t30 Jun 2023 A country that wants to make the world’s most advanced chips, and has a stated target for doing so, is a customer whose most capable purchases a government is entitled to examine. Examination is not prohibition. It is what a licence is.

The weak point lies elsewhere, in the machines already sold. ASML has shipped more than €8bn of DUV equipment to China since 2014, and in March it was unclear whether it could still service it.2CNBCDutch to restrict semiconductor tech exports to China, joining U.S.9 Mar 2023 The rule as written looks forward. Clarity about what happens to the installed base would serve customers and ASML better than a licence regime that officials can read however they please.

The Dutch have shown restraint, which in export control is rarer than it should be. They should now show they can keep it.