Eighteen countries, plus America, may buy as many American AI chips as they like.2The White House, via the American Presidency ProjectFact Sheet: Ensuring U.S. Security and Economic Strength in the Age of Artificial Intelligence13 Jan 2025 The rest of the world must queue. That is the core of the “Framework for Artificial Intelligence Diffusion”, an interim final rule from Commerce’s Bureau of Industry and Security, issued on January 13th.1Bureau of Industry and Security, US Department of Commerce, Federal RegisterFramework for Artificial Intelligence Diffusion (interim final rule)15 Jan 2025 The favoured 18 include Britain, Japan, Germany, South Korea and Taiwan. China, Russia, Iran and the other arms-embargoed states make up Tier 3. Tier 2 is “any country not identified in Tier 1 or Tier 3”, which is to say most of the planet.3Covington & BurlingU.S. Department of Commerce Establishes Export Control Framework Limiting the Diffusion of Advanced Artificial Intelligence and Expands and Clarifies Advanced Computing Controls
Tier 2 is where the rule bites. Orders of up to about 1,700 advanced GPUs need no licence. Trusted firms headquartered in close allies may place up to 7% of their global compute anywhere. Everyone else outside the club may buy the equivalent of up to 50,000 advanced GPUs per country, a ceiling that doubles to 100,000 if the government signs an agreement with Washington.2The White House, via the American Presidency ProjectFact Sheet: Ensuring U.S. Security and Economic Strength in the Age of Artificial Intelligence13 Jan 2025 The rule also creates a new export control, ECCN 4E091, on the weights (the trained parameters) of advanced closed models, set at those trained with 10^26 or more operations.3Covington & BurlingU.S. Department of Commerce Establishes Export Control Framework Limiting the Diffusion of Advanced Artificial Intelligence and Expands and Clarifies Advanced Computing Controls Exporters need not comply until May 15th, the same date comments are due.1Bureau of Industry and Security, US Department of Commerce, Federal RegisterFramework for Artificial Intelligence Diffusion (interim final rule)15 Jan 2025
We think the administration has got two halves of this right and one badly wrong. The aim is sound: the White House cites weapons of mass destruction, offensive cyber operations and mass surveillance as the risks of powerful AI in the wrong hands.2The White House, via the American Presidency ProjectFact Sheet: Ensuring U.S. Security and Economic Strength in the Age of Artificial Intelligence13 Jan 2025 Keeping the most advanced chips from China, and requiring security standards for closed model weights, follows from that. Better, the rule leaves open-weight models alone, and admits there are “no open-weight models known to have been trained on more than 10^26 computational operations”.1Bureau of Industry and Security, US Department of Commerce, Federal RegisterFramework for Artificial Intelligence Diffusion (interim final rule)15 Jan 2025 A control on a frontier nobody has yet crossed in the open costs little, and it is cheaper to write the rule before the model than after.
The wrong half is the cap. A country that is neither ally nor adversary is told that its compute has a ceiling, and that the ceiling is America’s to raise. Israel, India and Singapore are not on the list of 18, so by the rule’s own definition they sit in Tier 2 with the rest.3Covington & BurlingU.S. Department of Commerce Establishes Export Control Framework Limiting the Diffusion of Advanced Artificial Intelligence and Expands and Clarifies Advanced Computing Controls These are customers and partners, and the rule treats them as a risk to be metered.
The strongest case for the rule is leakage. BIS says transactions with an “elevated risk of diversion or misuse” deserve scrutiny, and a chip sold in one country can end up in another.1Bureau of Industry and Security, US Department of Commerce, Federal RegisterFramework for Artificial Intelligence Diffusion (interim final rule)15 Jan 2025 Caps on whole countries are crude, runs the argument, but they do not depend on trusting every buyer. That is fair as far as it goes. But the rule already has a better tool. A verified end-user route lets a firm that meets security requirements buy compute equivalent to up to 320,000 advanced GPUs over two years, whatever its address.2The White House, via the American Presidency ProjectFact Sheet: Ensuring U.S. Security and Economic Strength in the Age of Artificial Intelligence13 Jan 2025 If audits of buyers can manage diversion, caps on countries are surplus. They penalise the honest purchasers in a Tier 2 state for the sins of unnamed ones.
Nvidia, which has an interest, calls the rule one that “would do nothing to enhance U.S. security”.4NVIDIANVIDIA Statement on the Biden Administration’s Misguided ‘AI Diffusion’ Rule13 Jan 2025 That is too strong. The chip controls and the weights rule do something. But Nvidia’s companion point carries more weight: that “America wins through innovation, competition and by sharing our technologies with the world”.4NVIDIANVIDIA Statement on the Biden Administration’s Misguided ‘AI Diffusion’ Rule13 Jan 2025 A rule meant to spread American AI abroad, and to make it the default, should be judged on whether foreigners can in fact buy it.
There is also the matter of who will run it. The rule is interim, comments are open until May 15th, and the administration that wrote it leaves office a week from today.1Bureau of Industry and Security, US Department of Commerce, Federal RegisterFramework for Artificial Intelligence Diffusion (interim final rule)15 Jan 2025 An embargo with a sunset is a hard thing to build allies around.
Washington has built a velvet rope and given it a number. Those standing outside it will have noticed that the number is two.