Congress told ByteDance to sell TikTok or lose America. The law it passed says a sale counts only if it “precludes the establishment or maintenance of any operational relationship” between the American business and its old owner, including “any cooperation with respect to the operation of a content recommendation algorithm”.3US Government Publishing OfficePublic Law 118-50, Division H: Protecting Americans from Foreign Adversary Controlled Applications Act24 Apr 2024 On January 23rd the new owners announced a business with exactly such a relationship, and called it compliant.1TikTok NewsroomAnnouncement from the new TikTok USDS Joint Venture LLC23 Jan 2026
The terms are public. TikTok USDS Joint Venture LLC is held 15% each by Silver Lake, Oracle and MGX, with another group of investors, including Dell’s family office and Xavier Niel’s, making up part of the rest.1TikTok NewsroomAnnouncement from the new TikTok USDS Joint Venture LLC23 Jan 2026 ByteDance keeps 19.9%.1TikTok NewsroomAnnouncement from the new TikTok USDS Joint Venture LLC23 Jan 2026 The venture’s seven-person board has a majority of Americans and includes Shou Chew, TikTok’s chief executive, and Kenneth Glueck of Oracle.1TikTok NewsroomAnnouncement from the new TikTok USDS Joint Venture LLC23 Jan 2026 American user data will sit in Oracle’s cloud, and the recommendation algorithm will be retrained on that data and hosted there.1TikTok NewsroomAnnouncement from the new TikTok USDS Joint Venture LLC23 Jan 2026 The venture, run by Adam Presser as chief executive, will decide trust and safety policy and content moderation.1TikTok NewsroomAnnouncement from the new TikTok USDS Joint Venture LLC23 Jan 2026
Now the awkward part. The same announcement says the American entities of “TikTok global” will manage “global product interoperability and certain commercial activities”, including e-commerce, advertising and marketing.1TikTok NewsroomAnnouncement from the new TikTok USDS Joint Venture LLC23 Jan 2026 That is an operational relationship, with a stated list of duties. We think it is also the right call, and that the statute says otherwise.
It is the right call because the alternative was worse. A clean break, with no cooperation of any sort, means an American app that cannot talk to the global one. Creators lose their audiences abroad, advertisers lose a single system to buy on, and users get a product that decays. The September executive order that framed the deal asked for something narrower: ByteDance and its affiliates owning “less than 20 percent”, the algorithms and code under the venture’s control, retrained on American data, and watched by “trusted security partners”.2The White HouseSaving TikTok While Protecting National Security25 Sept 2025 Those are reasonable safeguards. They are not a divorce.
The strongest objection is that this is all lawful. The statute leaves the call to the president, who must decide through an interagency process that a transaction is a qualified divestiture, and the order duly says that the framework meets the test once the agreements are signed.2The White HouseSaving TikTok While Protecting National Security25 Sept 2025 3US Government Publishing OfficePublic Law 118-50, Division H: Protecting Americans from Foreign Adversary Controlled Applications Act24 Apr 2024 We concede the point on process. But a lawful finding is not a faithful one. The test Congress wrote has two limbs: the app must no longer be controlled by a foreign adversary, and it must have no operational relationship with the old owner.3US Government Publishing OfficePublic Law 118-50, Division H: Protecting Americans from Foreign Adversary Controlled Applications Act24 Apr 2024 The deal plainly satisfies the first. It is hard to see how it satisfies the second without reading “any” to mean “some”.
This matters beyond one app. The penalty hanging over the sale was up to $5,000 for each American user who kept using a banned app.3US Government Publishing OfficePublic Law 118-50, Division H: Protecting Americans from Foreign Adversary Controlled Applications Act24 Apr 2024 A threat that size shapes the bargaining table, and a rule that the executive may soften whenever the bargain looks good is a rule that foreign firms will learn to price. The next company in the statute’s sights will ask what the old test really required. Nobody will be able to say.
So we would change the law, not the facts. Congress should amend the definition to say what cooperation is allowed, such as commercial activity at arm’s length and interoperability with security monitoring, and what is not. That keeps the safeguards the deal contains and removes the fiction that it contains none of the thing the law forbids. If lawmakers think the deal too generous, the amendment is also the place to say so, in public and by vote.
Congress ordered a divorce. It has received a legal separation in which the parties still share a product.